The bill, in plain English

What PAPTA does

PAPTA has three titles. Title I holds prosecutors accountable for deliberate misconduct and adds transparency before charges. Title II makes DOJ's own grand jury rules binding. Title III limits asset freezes before trial. Titles II and III are written so each could also stand alone. Jump to transparency.

1

A narrow civil remedy

People harmed by 13 deliberate acts can sue. That covers state and local prosecutors, and federal prosecutors through an express claim. Civil liability applies only to future conduct.

2

Real protection for good faith

Negligence and reasonable mistakes are never actionable. There is a good-faith defense, early screening of weak complaints, and no inference from an acquittal.

3

Independent oversight

An Office of Prosecutorial Integrity inside the DOJ Inspector General, with due process before any finding, written reasons for every closure, and outside audits.

4

A second look at related cases

After a finding of misconduct, affected cases are identified, people are notified, and an independent reviewer examines them. Relief is not automatic.

5

Transparency before charges

Recorded witness and cooperator interviews, notice before charges in white-collar cases, written plea offers, and a record of every benefit promised to a cooperator.

6

Honest public statements

Press releases use presumption-of-innocence language. After an acquittal or dismissal, a notice of equal prominence follows within 2 business days.

7

Grand jury integrity

Evidence of innocence presented, targets heard, jurors told the decision is theirs alone, and the record available to the defense after indictment.

8

Property before trial

Pretrial restraint limited to property tied to the offense, with funds released for counsel, living and business expenses, and a prompt hearing.

9

Public data, never accusations

Annual reporting by district and a public database of final findings only. No one is listed on an allegation.

Transparency and property, stage by stage

Most of these rules already exist inside the Justice Department as internal policy, and the Justice Manual says it creates no enforceable rights. PAPTA would make them binding. Transparency runs to the defense in its own case, and to the public only in aggregate.

StageTodayWhat PAPTA would requireWhere
Witness interviewsRecording is presumed only for custodial interviews by certain agencies, so most witness interviews are summarized, not recordedRecord every interview of a witness, subject, target or potential cooperator, including proffers, from start to finish. Narrow exceptions (the person declines, equipment failure, emergencies, classified sources), each documented. Backup copy, chain of custody, rough notes preserved, recordings produced to the defenseSec. 21
Before chargesTarget notice is encouraged, not required, and notice that target status has ended is left to each U.S. AttorneyWhite-collar cases: written notice to a target before charges, a chance to submit a statement or meet with prosecutors, self-surrender instead of arrest, and written notice within 30 days when target status ends. Exceptions for flight, evidence or witness risk, in writingSec. 22
Grand jury: the target's voiceDOJ policy says requests to testify should get favorable consideration, but the manual creates no enforceable rightNotice to targets before indictment. A request to testify is granted unless refused in writing, and the grand jury is told of the request. Written statements and evidence go to the grand jury unless a court allows otherwise. Written advice of rights with every subpoenaTitle II, Secs. 206 to 208
Grand jury: evidence of innocenceDOJ policy to present it is unenforceable after United States v. Williams (1992)A binding duty to present substantial evidence that directly negates guilt, and a bar on evidence known to come from a clear constitutional violation or already suppressed by a courtTitle II, Secs. 204 and 205
Grand jury: jurorsJurors hear only what the prosecutor presentsThe court instructs jurors that they are independent, that the decision to indict is theirs alone, and that they may ask for evidence that may show innocenceTitle II, Sec. 209(a)
Grand jury: the recordProceedings are recorded, but the defense must show "particularized need" to see themAfter indictment, the defense gets the prosecutor's instructions and statements, and the testimony bearing on the charges, under a protective order. Inspector General review and annual public reporting by districtTitle II, Secs. 209 to 211
DiscoveryLarge unindexed productions can arrive just before a plea deadlineIndexed, searchable discovery in time to review before any plea deadline, and interview reports and recordings under one national deadline after arraignmentSec. 12(a)
CooperatorsPromises to cooperators surface piecemeal, if at allA written record of every promise, payment, immunity deal, charging or sentencing concession or immigration benefit, produced to the defenseSec. 12(g)
PleaOffers can be oral and lapse unrecordedEvery formal plea offer and deadline in writing and placed on the record. All evidence of innocence disclosed before a guilty plea, and a written theory of each count in white-collar cases on requestSec. 12(f), (h), (i)
Favorable evidenceA defendant can plead without knowing what was withheldProsecutors certify that favorable evidence (Brady and Giglio) was disclosed before plea, trial and sentencingSec. 12(a)
Public statementsCharges are announced loudly, acquittals quietly, and people never charged can be namedPresumption-of-innocence language, corrections, and an equal-prominence notice within 2 business days of an acquittal or dismissal. No naming of uncharged people as wrongdoersSec. 15
Property before trialAssets can be frozen or seized before trial, sometimes far beyond what is tied to the alleged offenseRestraint limited to traceable property, capped at the alleged loss in fraud cases. Untainted funds released for counsel, living and business expenses. A prompt hearing, no sale before verdict, and return with interest after acquittal or dismissalTitle III
Public dataPatterns stay hidden in national totalsAnnual reports by district: pleas, trials and dismissals, target notices, unrecorded interviews, grand jury no-bills, Hyde Amendment awards, and property seized, forfeited and returnedSecs. 18, 211, 312

Every provision above is in the October 2026 discussion draft. Some time periods are left open for the sponsor to set.

The 13 actionable acts

Most require knowing or intentional conduct. Recklessness counts only for failing to correct false evidence and for disclosure failures. The acts are covered in grand jury proceedings too.

  1. Fabricating, altering or planting evidence
  2. Soliciting or coercing testimony known to be false
  3. Presenting false evidence, or failing to correct it
  4. Suppressing favorable evidence
  5. Destroying or concealing evidence
  6. Making false statements to a court
  7. Retaliatory prosecution without probable cause
  8. Concealing conflicts of interest or violating a recusal duty
  9. Obstructing court orders on disclosure or evidence
  10. Directing others to do any of these
  11. Prosecuting for a private party's financial benefit or for partisan advantage, or letting an interested party direct the case
  12. Bringing charges known to lack probable cause
  13. Making knowingly prejudicial public statements

Section by section

Sec.TitleWhat it does
1Short title, table of contentsNames the Act. Titles II and III each operate on their own
2Findings and purposesThe legal basis and the Act's purposes
3DefinitionsCovered prosecutor, covered misconduct, state of mind, related case, white-collar offense
4State and local prosecutorsCivil remedy for the 13 acts, including in grand jury proceedings, prospective only
5Federal prosecutorsAn express claim against the United States and the individual. Not a Bivens claim
6Proof, defenses, remediesNegligence never actionable, a good-faith defense, a 4-year filing window, no federal funds for punitive damages
7Prosecutorial independenceCharging, plea and sentencing decisions protected. No inference from acquittal
8Office of Prosecutorial IntegrityIndependent investigation inside the Inspector General, with tracked intake, written reasons, audits and conflict rules
9Related-case reviewA second look at cases touched by proven misconduct
10Federal conviction reviewA path back to the sentencing court, with counsel
11State grantsVoluntary grants for states that adopt similar systems
12Brady, Giglio and evidence integrityDisclosure certification, indexed discovery, written plea offers, cooperator benefits record
13ConflictsDisclosure, recusal, no outside pay
14Independence from private and partisan interestsNo case brought for a private party's gain or partisan advantage
15Accuracy of official statementsPresumption of innocence, corrections, disposition notices, protection for uncharged people
16Misconduct databaseFinal findings only, never allegations
17Whistleblower and witness protectionsProtected disclosures and anti-retaliation
18Data and economic impact reportingAnnual public report, by district
19Rules, funding, effective datesRules within 1 year, phased effective dates
20Rules of constructionNo narrowing of existing rights. The Office can't direct charging
21Recording of interviewsWitness and cooperator interviews recorded in full
22Pre-charge noticeTarget notice and self-surrender in white-collar cases
201 to 213Title II: Grand jury integrityEvidence of innocence, target notice and testimony, advice of rights, juror instructions, defense access to the record, Inspector General enforcement, annual reporting
301 to 313Title III: Pretrial restraint of propertyTraceable property only, loss cap, release for counsel and expenses, prompt hearing, operating businesses, no sale before verdict, return with interest, reporting

Summary of the October 2026 discussion draft. The full text is available to congressional offices and partner organizations on request.

“A government of laws and not of men.” John Adams, Massachusetts Constitution, 1780

PAPTA is a model act developed by the Justice Restoration Foundation (Kingdom Business Builders, Inc. dba Justice Restoration Foundation), a nonpartisan 501(c)(3). JRF Model Act, discussion draft of October 2026. Prior versions are archived.

PAPTA is not legal advice. JRF does not provide legal representation.

justicerestorationfoundation.org · Privacy · Terms